Insights

The 2020 Anomaly

On the season chart, the pandemic year looks like the moment bucking bulls suddenly got better: the 45+ rate jumped by half in a single season. We decomposed it. The bulls didn't change — 93 of them bucked in both 2019 and 2020 and scored within 0.03 points of themselves. What changed was who got hauled.

Pull up Score Inflation and one season sticks out of the curve like a broken finger. In 2019, 2.9% of all recorded outs scored 45 or better. In 2020 — the year the sport ran on empty arenas and a gutted calendar — that rate jumped to 4.4%. Read naively, the pandemic season was the biggest one-year leap in bull quality ever recorded.

Nobody who watched that season believes that. So what actually happened?

SeasonScored outsDistinct bullsAvg score45+ rate
2017 6,042 1,227 41.98 2.3%
2018 6,357 1,248 42.08 2.5%
2019 6,457 1,218 42.20 2.9%
2020 4,118 1,056 42.35 4.4%
2021 5,832 1,125 42.59 5.4%
2022 7,547 1,296 42.41 5.3%
2023 8,461 1,378 42.04 3.1%

All circuits, all recorded outs with a bull score.

First, rule out the yardstick

The cleanest test: find every bull who took five or more premier-series trips in both 2019 and 2020, and compare him to himself. There are 93 such bulls. Their 2019 average: 43.07. Their 2020 average: 43.11. A within-bull change of +0.03 points — statistical silence. The judges scored the same bulls the same way in the strangest season of their lives. The yardstick never moved.

What moved was the roster

Look instead at the outs column. The sport ran 4,118 recorded outs in 2020, down 36% from 6,457 the year before. The national circuits nearly vanished — 467 recorded outs in 2019, just 203 in 2020 — and the US touring ranks were cut nearly in half. When a contractor gets half the chute gates, the bulls left home aren't the best ones: the share of premier-series outs taken by career-elite bulls (44+ career average) rose from 3.1% in 2019 to 5.0% in 2020 — a sixty-percent concentration of the sport's best stock into its shrunken calendar.

Fewer trips, disproportionately given to better bulls, each scored exactly as they'd always been scored: the average rises, the 45+ rate jumps, and not a single animal got better or a single judge got looser. The anomaly is arithmetic.

The echo — and the reversal

The elevated rates lingered through 2021 and 2022 as the calendar rebuilt around premier and Team Series competition. Then look at 2023: 8,461 outs — the biggest season in the record — and the 45+ rate falls back to 3.1%, right where the pre-pandemic trend left it. The expansion years reversed the concentration: more gates for developmental and national stock diluted the mix exactly the way 2020 had concentrated it. Mix giveth, and mix taketh away.

Why this matters beyond 2020

This is the same lesson Scoring by Circuit taught across geography, now proven across time: an average is a statement about who got scored, not just how well they bucked. It's why cross-era comparisons on this site lean on per-bull records rather than league averages, and why the world title is decided by a championship average inside one circuit's season — a design that shrugs off exactly this kind of composition shift. The 2020 spike isn't a flaw in the data. Left unexplained, it's a flaw in how the data gets read — and now it's explained.